Simplifying Kids Activities: Why Less Really Is More for Our Family’s Sanity

I’ll be honest—our family was exhausted. Mentally, physically, financially… the whole thing. Between homeschooling, running a household, and keeping up with extracurriculars, we were running ourselves into the ground.

So this year, we made a huge shift: simplifying kids activities. Not because we don’t value enrichment or opportunities for our girls, but because we realized our mental health, family connection, and actual joy were getting lost in the shuffle.

Be sure to subscribe to our monthly newsletter to be an insider and to follow along with our days over on Instagram @makingeverydaymagic.

The Trap of More, More, More

We’ve been homeschooling for nine years, and somewhere along the way, we fell headfirst into the “more is better” mindset when it came to kids extracurriculars. Sports, arts, music, clubs—you name it, we tried it.

The thing is, even after recognizing the problem, we still participated in the same cycle. We’d fill our schedule with high-commitment, high-cost extras, telling ourselves it was all “for the kids.” But the truth? It was wearing everyone down.

Why We’re Choosing Simplicity Now

Life threw us some curveballs last year—home repairs, selling a house, moving. We struggled to stay on track, and it hit me: I was doing things the same old way just because it was habit.

But now, with an eighth grader diving into heavier academics and a fourth grader discovering her passions, we’re rethinking everything. My girls have found the activities they truly love—musical theater for my oldest, art and Girl Scouts for my youngest. That’s where our focus will stay.

Simplifying kids activities means giving them boundaries, not cutting them off from joy. Our new rule: extracurriculars on just two days a week whenever possible.

The Problem With Activity Overload

We live in a culture that treats kids’ schedules like Olympic training plans.
Five-year-olds in dance class six days a week. Travel ball every season. Private lessons stacked on top of regular practices.

And for what? Most kids won’t go pro in sports or the arts. But families are spending thousands—sometimes tens of thousands—of dollars each year chasing the “leg up.”

It’s not just the money. The time cost is enormous. Families miss meals together. Weekends vanish in a blur of tournaments, recitals, and competitions. And the pressure on kids to perform? It’s exhausting for them too.

How We’re Simplifying Kids Extracurriculars

Here’s what’s working for us:

• Set clear boundaries. Two days a week for activities is our goal.

• Prioritize passion over pressure. The girls’ activities are based on what they love, not what’s trendy or expected.

• Count school-day activities separately. Music lessons and homeschool-day clubs don’t eat into evening family time.

• Allow for special exceptions. A short-term performance or special project is fine—if it has a clear end date.

• Protect family time. Home-cooked dinners together at least four nights a week are non-negotiable.

Why This Matters for Mental Health

Pulling back on activities has given us space to breathe. We’re less stressed, less rushed, and more present with each other. The girls still get to grow in their interests, but now we all have the energy to actually enjoy them.

Most importantly, it’s reminded us that not everything our kids do needs to be a stepping stone to some future career or scholarship. It’s okay for things to just be fun.

A Final Reminder for Fellow Parents

If you’ve been feeling suffocated by your kids’ extracurriculars, I promise—you’re not alone. Simplifying kids activities doesn’t mean depriving your kids; it means giving them (and you) the gift of time, space, and connection.

Set boundaries. Say no when it’s too much. And remember, family dinners and board games can be just as valuable as practices and lessons.

Your kids will still thrive—and you’ll still have the energy to make everyday magic together.