How We’re Building a Custom Homeschool High School Around Our Daughter’s Interests

What would you build if you could design your child’s high school experience from scratch?

Not simply choose a curriculum.

Not simply decide which textbooks they should use.

Actually build the experience around their interests, strengths, goals, and the future they might want.

That’s the question I’ve been asking myself as we enter our first year of homeschooling high school.

And somewhere along the way, I realized that we are essentially building a custom homeschool high school modeled, in part, on something I hadn’t even consciously been trying to recreate: a performing arts magnet school.

Be sure to subscribe to our monthly newsletter to be an insider and to follow along with our days over on Instagram @makingeverydaymagic.

Our Homeschool High School Doesn’t Look Like Traditional High School

We are in our 10th year of homeschooling, and our daughter is now a ninth grader.

For years, our job was primarily to build a strong academic foundation.

We wanted her to be challenged.

We wanted her to stay ahead academically.

We wanted to know that if she eventually decided to pursue college, competitive programs, or something else entirely, we hadn’t accidentally closed doors by choosing to homeschool.

But we didn’t know exactly what those future doors would be.

And that’s important.

Because I think sometimes homeschool parents feel like they have to know the entire four-year plan before they even begin high school.

I don’t think that’s true.

You can build a strong foundation before you know exactly where your child is going.

Then you can adjust.

You can pay attention.

You can follow the learner.

And when the direction becomes clearer, you can pour more resources into it.

That’s essentially what has happened for us.

We’re Building Around Her Actual Interests

My daughter knows that she wants to pursue performing arts.

That changes the equation.

We’re not simply adding dance or theater to the bottom of a traditional academic schedule as an afterthought.

We’re treating those interests as a meaningful part of her education.

That means serious performance opportunities.

It means continuing to develop skills.

It means finding instruction and experiences that challenge her.

It means making room in the schedule for opportunities that might happen during the traditional school day.

And it means recognizing that what some schools might categorize as an extracurricular activity can actually be an important part of a student’s educational and professional trajectory.

At the same time, I am not willing to sacrifice academics.

In fact, the opposite is true.

Academics Still Matter—A Lot

Our daughter is taking Algebra 2 in ninth grade.

We’re looking at advanced coursework and an eventual dual-credit path.

We’re thinking about transcripts, documentation, and how we’re going to demonstrate what she’s accomplished.

Because following a child’s interests doesn’t mean abandoning academic rigor.

I actually think those two things can make each other stronger.

A student who is deeply invested in a particular field can have a reason to work harder, learn more, and develop skills at a much higher level.

And that’s what I want for her.

I want her to be able to dance, sing, act, perform, create and pursue the things she loves.

But I also want her to have math.

Science.

History.

Writing.

Critical thinking.

The academic foundation that allows her to walk into whatever room comes next and be prepared to participate.

Then I Discovered the Magnet School Connection

At one point, my daughter briefly considered attending a local performing arts magnet program.

If you’re unfamiliar with magnet schools, the basic idea is that they can offer a specialized educational environment built around a particular area of interest.

There might be magnet programs focused on medicine, engineering, science and technology, languages, performing arts, visual arts, and other specialized areas.

The performing arts program we were considering would essentially divide the student’s time between academics and the specialized arts program.

And that stopped me.

Because I realized:

That’s what we’re doing.

We’re just doing it at home.

We’re taking the basic framework of a specialized high school and asking:

How can we make this work for OUR learner?

A Magnet-Style Homeschool at Home

Our days don’t look exactly like a traditional school schedule.

We have a block of advanced academics.

We have time for real-life learning and the things that come with actually living a life.

And we have significant time and energy devoted to performance.

Some of those opportunities happen outside traditional school hours.

Some don’t.

And because we’re homeschooling, we’re able to adjust when something important comes up.

That’s one of the pieces of freedom I don’t want to take for granted.

If she has a daytime performance opportunity, she doesn’t automatically have to choose between that opportunity and school.

We can build the school around the opportunity.

That’s what customization means to me.

But This Isn’t Just About Performing Arts

The most important thing I’ve realized is that this model isn’t actually about my daughter being a performer.

It’s about learning how to build an education around a learner.

My younger daughter is not on the same path.

Her interests are different.

Her strengths are different.

Her goals may be completely different.

And that’s okay.

Now that I’ve seen what it looks like to build a high school around one child’s strengths, I have a framework I can use again.

If my younger daughter becomes an elite swimmer, we can build around swimming.

If she becomes obsessed with engineering, we can build around engineering.

If she wants to pursue something I can’t even imagine right now, we’ll figure that out too.

The point isn’t the particular interest.

The point is the intentionality.

What About College?

This is where I think the academic rigor becomes particularly important.

I don’t know whether my daughter will go to college.

Maybe she will.

Maybe she won’t.

Maybe she’ll go directly into a performance-based career.

Maybe she’ll change her mind entirely.

I have no idea.

And I don’t need to know.

What I DO know is that I want to make sure that every possible door is open when she gets to the point where she needs to choose.

That means taking academics seriously.

It means keeping records.

It means building a transcript.

It means pursuing advanced coursework where appropriate.

It means finding outside experts when we need them.

It means making sure that what we’re doing can be explained clearly to someone who wasn’t here watching us do it.

If she decides she wants college, I don’t want homeschooling to be the reason she can’t pursue a particular opportunity.

If she decides she doesn’t want college, I don’t want the lack of a college plan to have prevented her from building the skills she needs.

My job is to get her there.

Her job is to break down the door.

You Don’t Have to Know the Destination Yet

This may actually be my biggest takeaway after ten years of homeschooling.

You don’t have to know what your child will become.

You don’t have to know exactly what their high school will look like when they’re in elementary school.

You can focus on building the foundation.

Teach them well.

Keep the academics strong.

Expose them to lots of things.

Pay attention to what lights them up.

Pay attention to what they’re naturally good at.

Then, when you start seeing a direction, you can build into it.

That’s what we’re doing now.

We spent years building a foundation without knowing that performing arts would eventually become such a significant part of our high school plan.

And now that we know?

We’re going all in.

Not instead of academics.

Not instead of preparing for the real world.

Because we want to prepare her for the real world.

Homeschooling Doesn’t Have to Mean Doing Less

There are plenty of conversations happening right now about homeschooling.

Some criticism is fair.

Some stereotypes come from real experiences.

But I also think it’s important to remember that homeschoolers aren’t one homogeneous group.

There are families homeschooling for a thousand different reasons.

And there are families building wildly different educational experiences.

For us, homeschooling isn’t about sitting behind closed doors and letting the world happen to us.

It’s about getting out there.

Finding opportunities.

Finding experts.

Finding resources.

Building relationships.

Pursuing advanced academics.

Developing talents.

And making sure our kids are ready for whatever comes next.

I don’t need to know exactly what that “next” will be.

I just want to make sure we’re prepared for it.

And that’s the beauty of a custom homeschool high school.

We don’t have to start with the question, “How do we recreate traditional high school at home?”

We can start with a much better question:

“What does THIS child need?”

And then we can build from there.

That’s what we’re doing.

And honestly, after ten years of homeschooling, it feels pretty amazing to realize that all those years of laying foundations prepared us for a high school experience we didn’t even know we were building toward.

We’re still figuring it out.

We’ll keep adjusting.

We’ll outsource when we need to.

We’ll bring in experts.

We’ll change things when our learner changes.

But for right now, we’ve got our framework.

Advanced academics.

Serious performance opportunities.

Real-world experiences.

Flexibility.

Documentation.

And a whole lot of intentionality.

That’s our version of high school.

And we’re pretty excited to see where it takes us.

What would you put into your child’s custom high school? I’d love to hear what you’re building—or what you wish you could build.

Keep making everyday magic.