How I Homeschool Multiple Grades: Combining 9th and 5th Grade

One of the things people ask me most often about homeschooling is some version of:

How do you homeschool multiple kids when they’re in completely different grades?

And I understand the question.

I have a 9th grader and a 5th grader. They are four grade levels apart. They’re not close in age, they’re not close in developmental stage, and they definitely don’t have the same academic skill set.

But they also don’t need two completely separate homeschool programs.

After 10 years of homeschooling, I’ve gotten pretty comfortable with figuring out which things need to be individual and which things are actually better when we do them together.

That distinction has made a huge difference in our homeschool.

Be sure to subscribe to our monthly newsletter to be an insider and to follow along with our days over on Instagram @makingeverydaymagic.

We don’t try to make everything the same

This is probably the most important thing.

When I say that we combine subjects, I don’t mean that my 5th grader is doing 9th-grade work.

And I definitely don’t mean that my 9th grader is being held back to 5th-grade expectations.

They’re learning together, but they’re not necessarily producing the same thing.

That difference matters.

For us, there are some subjects that are very specifically tied to grade level and individual skill development.

Math stays individual.

My 9th grader needs the math she’s ready for.

My 5th grader needs the math she’s ready for.

There isn’t much benefit to forcing those two things together just for the sake of having one lesson.

Language arts stays individual, too.

Language development, grammar, writing, and literature expectations change dramatically as kids get older.

Even when my kids are studying related concepts, the depth of what I expect from them is different.

And that’s okay.

In fact, I think that’s one of the beautiful things about homeschooling.

We can give two children access to the same general subject while respecting the fact that they are different people at different stages of development.

What we DO combine

This is where homeschooling multiple ages gets really interesting.

I look for subjects that naturally lend themselves to group learning.

For us, that’s often:

• History
• Science
• Art history
• Geography
• French
• Other “bonus” studies we’re interested in exploring together

These subjects tend to work beautifully as a group because there is so much information that can simply be experienced together.

We can watch the same video.

We can read about the same historical event.

We can look at the same map.

We can conduct the same science experiment.

We can discuss the same idea.

And then each child can respond at their own level.

That saves me time, but that’s not the only reason I do it.

Group learning is often more fun.

Science experiments are more fun when everyone is involved.

History discussions are more interesting when there are multiple people asking questions.

And I genuinely like having my kids learning alongside each other.

I don’t want our homeschool to become two completely separate schools happening in the same house.

Teach to the older child and pull the younger one up

This is one of the philosophies that has worked especially well for us.

When we’re combining a subject, I generally teach toward the older child’s level and pull the younger child into the experience.

That doesn’t mean I expect my younger child to perform at the older child’s level.

It means I give her access to ideas that she might not otherwise encounter yet.

For example, we’re doing biology this year.

My 9th grader is working through biology at a high-school level.

My 5th grader is very interested in animals, so she can absolutely participate in that learning.

She might learn about animal cells.

She might color and label a cell.

She might learn about taxonomy.

She might do a matching activity.

Meanwhile, my 9th grader might be expected to remember terminology, explain concepts, write about them, or complete a much more sophisticated assignment.

They’re both learning biology.

They’re just not being asked to demonstrate that learning in the same way.

Same lesson. Different expectations.

This is probably the biggest key to making combined homeschooling work.

Last year, when we studied Black American history, I could give both kids access to the same content while changing the work that came afterward.

My older child might have an open-ended assignment requiring complete sentences and more independent thinking.

My younger child might have a word bank and matching activity.

Neither assignment is “better.”

They’re simply appropriate for different developmental stages.

I want to pour a lot into both of my kids.

But I also want what I expect from them to be reasonable.

That’s an important distinction.

Why combining saves us so much time

We spend about half of our day on academics.

That’s with both individual work and combined work.

If I tried to teach every subject separately to each child, our academic day would expand dramatically.

And the funny thing is, the amount of actual student work wouldn’t necessarily increase.

I’d just be spending more time introducing, explaining, reading, setting up, transitioning, and managing the same kinds of lessons multiple times.

History is a great example.

We’re using Nomadic Professor for world history this year.

There are readings, audio, notes, timelines, maps, quizzes, and larger projects.

That’s a lot of material to work through.

Doing all of that twice would create a tremendous amount of unnecessary duplication.

Instead, we experience the history together.

Then the expectations for what each child does with that information can be different.

That is a much better use of our time.

Independence is part of the system

Combining subjects only works really well for us because my kids have also learned how to work independently.

This wasn’t something I suddenly expected them to know how to do when they got older.

We started when they were little.

When I was working with one child, the other child learned that there was something she could be doing.

Maybe it was a math page after we’d finished the lesson.

Maybe it was geography.

Maybe it was coloring letters while her older sister and I worked on phonics.

When my younger daughter was four, she wanted to be part of what we were doing.

She saw that everyone was learning.

Everyone was working.

It looked interesting.

So she wanted her own work, too.

And I let her participate.

She listened to lessons.

She sat in on things.

She colored.

She absorbed information.

She was simply part of the team.

Years later, that has become incredibly valuable.

Now my kids understand that if I’m working individually with one child, the other child doesn’t necessarily need me hovering beside them.

They know what they’re supposed to be doing.

They can stay on task.

They can get things done.

That independence is not accidental.

It’s something we built over time.

You don’t have to combine everything

There is a temptation, especially when you’re homeschooling multiple children, to think you have to find one curriculum that works for everyone.

I don’t think that’s necessary.

In fact, I think it can make things harder.

Some things genuinely need to be individual.

Some things naturally work as a group.

And some things can be combined while the assignments and expectations are differentiated.

That’s the sweet spot for us.

Combine where it makes sense.

Don’t combine simply because you’re trying to save yourself work.

And don’t keep everything separate simply because your children are different ages.

Look at the actual learning goal.

Ask yourself:

• Does this subject need to be taught at a specific grade level?
• Can everyone understand and participate in the same lesson?
• Can the output be adjusted by age?
• Will my kids benefit from doing this together?
• Am I creating unnecessary work for myself by duplicating this lesson?

Those questions have helped me tremendously.

What if your kids are REALLY far apart?

You can still use this idea even if your children are farther apart than mine.

Let’s say you have a 1st grader and a 9th grader.

Your 9th grader is studying biology.

That doesn’t mean your 1st grader has to sit there and understand a high-school biology textbook.

But she could learn about animals.

She could learn basic parts of a cell.

She could color and label an animal cell.

She could learn basic taxonomy.

She could listen to the discussion.

She can be part of the learning without being responsible for the same learning outcome.

That’s the distinction.

Participation doesn’t have to equal identical expectations.

The goal isn’t less education

I want to be really clear about this because “combine” can sometimes sound like “cut corners.”

That’s not what I’m talking about.

I’m not suggesting that you skip math.

I’m not suggesting that you don’t teach your children the language arts skills they need.

I’m not suggesting that younger kids don’t deserve developmentally appropriate instruction.

I’m saying that not every subject requires a completely separate lesson for every child.

If I can teach a history lesson once and then have two children engage with it at different levels, why wouldn’t I?

If we can do a science experiment together, why would I send everyone into separate rooms?

If we can all learn French together, why not?

For our family, combining these things gives us more time to actually enjoy our homeschool.

And that’s important to me.

I want my kids to learn together

This may actually be the biggest reason I continue to combine subjects.

I don’t want my kids constantly going their separate ways.

I don’t want our homeschool to feel like everyone has their own tiny school happening independently from everyone else.

One of the things I love about homeschooling is that we can learn together.

We can sit around the same table.

We can talk about what we’re learning.

We can hear each other’s questions.

We can learn from each other.

We can make science a group experience.

We can turn history into something we discuss instead of something that happens in isolation.

That feels like a huge part of what homeschooling is supposed to be for our family.

After 10 years, this is what works for us

I am not saying this is the only way to homeschool multiple children.

It isn’t.

If you have six kids who are all close together, your system may look completely different from mine.

If you have one child, you obviously don’t need to combine anything.

If you have toddlers and teenagers, you may have an entirely different set of challenges.

And my kids are older now. My youngest is in 5th grade and has spent years learning how our homeschool works.

So I’m always going to give that caveat.

But after 10 years of homeschooling, this is what works for us:

Keep the truly individual things individual.

Combine wherever it genuinely makes sense.

Teach toward the older child and pull the younger child into the learning.

Adjust expectations based on age and development.

Build independence early.

And perhaps most importantly:

You don’t have to recreate the traditional school model inside your house.

You can make something that works for the actual people who live there.

For us, that means a 9th grader and a 5th grader can spend part of their school day learning completely different things—and then come back together for history, science, geography, French, and whatever else makes sense.

That isn’t cutting corners.

That’s using the flexibility of homeschooling to our advantage.

And after 10 years?

I’m pretty happy with how that works.

Let’s keep making everyday magic.